Manchester City’s long-running dispute with the Premier League has taken another significant turn.

On 25 September 2026, reports said that an independent commission had found Manchester City in breach of almost all the financial rules charges brought against it. However, at the time of writing, the commission’s full decision and any sanction have not been officially published, and an appeal is expected.

It is also worth clearing up a common misconception: these are Premier League charges, not FA charges.

The Premier League first referred the alleged breaches to an independent commission in February 2023. They concern, among other matters, the accuracy of financial information supplied by the club, remuneration information, financial regulations and alleged failures to cooperate with the League’s investigation.

Much of the public discussion will understandably focus on possible points deductions, fines or other sporting consequences.

However, the Manchester City financial rules case also raises an important employment law question: what happens to individual employees and former employees who worked for an organisation that is found to have broken regulatory rules?

The answer is more complicated than simply attributing an organisation’s conduct to its staff.

A finding against an employer does not automatically make an employee guilty

Perhaps the most important employment law principle arising from a case like this is that corporate or regulatory responsibility and individual employee responsibility are not the same thing.

Even if a final ruling establishes that an organisation supplied inaccurate information or breached regulatory obligations, that does not automatically prove that every director, manager, accountant or other employee involved committed misconduct.

An employer considering disciplinary action would need to establish what a particular employee actually did.

That could involve examining their responsibilities, the information available to them at the time, instructions they received, decisions they personally made and whether they knew that anything improper was taking place.

Job title or seniority alone is not enough.

This distinction can be particularly important in large organisations. Financial reporting, contracts and commercial arrangements may involve numerous employees, external advisers and different levels of approval.

An employee may have acted on information supplied by someone else or reasonably relied on specialist legal or financial advice.

A regulator’s conclusion may therefore provide a reason to investigate an employee, but it should not replace the investigation itself.

Employees accused of misconduct are still entitled to a fair process

Where an employer believes that an employee may have been personally involved in wrongdoing, misconduct can potentially provide a fair reason for dismissal.

However, the employer must still act reasonably.

In practice, this means carrying out a proper investigation, explaining the allegations to the employee, giving them an opportunity to respond and reaching a decision based on the available evidence.

The current Acas Code remains an important benchmark for disciplinary proceedings. Acas has consulted on a replacement Code, but as at 29 September 2026, the replacement remains in draft form.

In a high-profile investigation, employers should be particularly careful not to identify a convenient individual to blame simply because they worked in the relevant department.

An organisation may be under considerable commercial and reputational pressure following an adverse regulatory finding. That pressure does not remove its employment law obligations.

What if an employee raised concerns internally?

Cases involving alleged financial irregularities can also raise important questions about whistleblowing and employment law.

Under the Employment Rights Act 1996, certain disclosures may qualify for statutory protection where a worker reasonably believes that the information tends to show matters such as a criminal offence, breach of a legal obligation or concealment of wrongdoing, and the relevant legal requirements are met.

A worker who makes a protected disclosure has legal protection against suffering certain detriments because of it. An employee dismissed because they made a protected disclosure may potentially bring an automatically unfair dismissal claim.

This can become particularly important where an employee has questioned accounting practices, objected to an instruction or raised concerns about information being supplied to a regulator.

Employers therefore need to distinguish genuine disciplinary issues from the fact that someone has previously raised concerns.

An employee does not become immune from disciplinary action simply because they are a whistleblower. If there is genuinely separate misconduct, the employer can investigate it.

What an employer cannot lawfully do is use a disciplinary process as retaliation for protected whistleblowing.

Can an NDA or settlement agreement prevent an employee from speaking out?

Confidentiality agreements are common where senior employees leave businesses, particularly where commercially sensitive information is involved.

However, their reach has limits.

Section 43J of the Employment Rights Act 1996 provides that contractual terms are void to the extent that they attempt to prevent a worker from making a protected disclosure.

Acas also explains that confidentiality clauses cannot be used to prevent whistleblowing or reporting a crime to the police.

That does not mean a departing employee can freely publish everything they learned during their employment. Legitimate obligations concerning confidential business information and trade secrets may continue after the employment relationship has ended.

The wording of the particular agreement, the nature of the information and who it is being disclosed to can all matter.

This is one reason why both employers and employees should consider obtaining specialist legal advice when negotiating settlement agreements involving regulatory investigations or allegations of wrongdoing.

What about former employees?

Leaving an organisation does not rewrite what happened while a person worked there.

A former employee obviously cannot be disciplined or dismissed from employment that has already ended. However, depending on the circumstances, contractual obligations, confidentiality provisions and claims relating to historic conduct may continue to be relevant.

A former employee may also remain an important witness to an internal, regulatory or court investigation.

Equally, resignation does not protect an organisation from liability for events which occurred before the employee left. If a company breached regulatory obligations while an individual worked there, that breach does not disappear simply because the individual subsequently moves on.

The same applies the other way around. Where there is evidence of personal wrongdoing, an employee does not necessarily escape potential civil or criminal responsibility simply by resigning.

Crucially, individual liability requires evidence against that individual. It cannot simply be inferred from the fact that they worked for the organisation.

What does Pep Guardiola’s departure tell us?

Pep Guardiola’s departure from Manchester City in May 2026 provides a useful example of why speculation about individual motives should be treated carefully.

There is currently no reliable evidence establishing that his departure was intended to protect Manchester City in connection with the Premier League proceedings.

Guardiola indicated that he intended to take a break from coaching after a decade in charge, while Manchester City confirmed that he would maintain a relationship with City Football Group as a global ambassador.

More importantly from a legal perspective, the specific allegations concerning undisclosed manager remuneration relate to a period before Guardiola became Manchester City manager.

His tenure did overlap with the later part of some of the wider periods covered by the Premier League case, but being present at an organisation at a particular time does not establish knowledge or involvement.

Nor would leaving the managerial role itself shield Manchester City from responsibility for earlier events.

The broader employment law lesson is straightforward: chronology and association are not substitutes for evidence.

What should employers do after a serious regulatory finding?

Where a regulator or independent body makes findings against an organisation, employers should avoid rushing immediately into disciplinary action.

The first priority should be preserving relevant evidence and establishing exactly which employees were involved in the matters under scrutiny.

Investigators should distinguish between witnesses, people responsible for implementing instructions and individuals who are actually suspected of misconduct.

Any investigation should be sufficiently independent, particularly where senior management may themselves be involved in the underlying events.

Employers should also identify potential whistleblowing issues at an early stage and make sure staff are not subjected to unlawful retaliation for raising concerns.

Where an individual faces possible personal regulatory, civil or criminal exposure, there can also be a conflict between the interests of the company and the employee.

Employees in that position should consider obtaining their own independent legal advice rather than assuming that the employer’s lawyers are also representing them personally.

Employment Tribunal deadlines are also changing

Anyone involved in an employment dispute should be careful about limitation periods.

From 1 October 2026, time limits for the majority of Employment Tribunal claims increase from three months to six months. Transitional provisions mean that the change applies where the relevant date occurs on or after 1 October 2026; earlier relevant dates do not automatically benefit from the new time limit.

There is another significant change approaching.

From 1 January 2027, the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal protection will reduce from two years to six months.

This means employers should already be preparing for the change. Employees who have accrued the necessary six months’ service by the time the new rules apply may fall within the new protection, subject to the relevant statutory provisions and transitional arrangements.

Automatically unfair dismissal protections operate differently and, depending on the particular right involved, may apply without the ordinary qualifying period.

Employment Tribunal deadlines can be complex. Employees should therefore avoid assuming that an internal investigation, grievance or appeal will automatically extend the applicable time limit.

Anyone concerned about a potential claim should obtain advice promptly and ensure they understand the applicable Acas Early Conciliation and Employment Tribunal deadlines.

The wider employment law lesson from the Manchester City case

Whatever the eventual sporting outcome of Manchester City’s Premier League case, its employment law implications illustrate a principle that applies far beyond football.

When an organisation is accused of serious wrongdoing, there can be an understandable desire to identify the individuals responsible. Employment law requires a more careful approach.

Employers need evidence relating to the particular employee, an appropriate investigation and a fair disciplinary process.

Whistleblowers have statutory protections. Confidentiality provisions cannot lawfully prevent protected disclosures. Former employees cannot automatically be blamed or absolved simply because they have left an organisation.

For employees, the message is equally important.

If you become involved in an internal investigation, are accused of misconduct, have raised concerns about wrongdoing or are being asked to sign a settlement agreement, the interests of your employer may not necessarily be the same as your own.

How Attwells Solicitors can help

Workplace investigations involving allegations of misconduct, whistleblowing or regulatory breaches can have serious consequences for both employees and businesses.

Attwells Solicitors’ Employment Law team can advise employees who are facing disciplinary allegations, raising concerns about wrongdoing or considering a settlement agreement.

We also support employers with workplace investigations, disciplinary procedures and managing employment risk fairly and lawfully.

If you are dealing with a difficult workplace situation and would like clear, practical advice about your options, contact Attwells Solicitors’ Employment Law team on 01206 766333.

Get In Touch Today!
Related articles
  • Senior executive negotiating a settlement agreement in a corporate boardroom
    Senior executive negotiating a settlement agreement in a corporate boardroom

    November 17, 2026

  • Attwells Solicitors' Employment Law Team, featured alongside the firm's Legal 500 Leading Firm recognition for 2027.
    Attwells Solicitors' Employment Law Team, featured alongside the firm's Legal 500 Leading Firm recognition for 2027.

    November 17, 2026

  • Job applicant discussing their CV during a job interview
    Job applicant discussing their CV during a job interview

    November 17, 2026

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!