A settlement agreement is a legally binding contract under which an employee gives up specified employment claims, usually in exchange for a payment. It is only valid if it meets six statutory conditions, including that you have taken advice from an independent adviser.

If you have just been handed one, the three questions that matter most are: what am I giving up, is the money right, and what can I change? This guide answers all three.

Key points at a glance

  • Settlement agreements are voluntary. You do not have to sign, and the first offer is rarely the final offer.
  • To be binding, the agreement must satisfy the six conditions in section 203(3) of the Employment Rights Act 1996 (and section 147 of the Equality Act 2010 for discrimination claims).
  • The Acas Code of Practice recommends you get at least 10 calendar days to consider the written terms.
  • The £30,000 tax exemption applies only to genuine termination payments. Notice pay, holiday and bonus are taxed in full.
  • Some rights cannot be signed away at all, including the right to blow the whistle and the right to report a crime.
  • Three reforms in 2026 and 2027 materially change employee bargaining power. If your termination date falls near 1 January 2027, that timing matters (see below).

What is a settlement agreement?

A settlement agreement is a written contract between an employer and a worker in which the worker agrees not to bring specified legal claims, usually in return for a payment and other agreed terms.

They were called compromise agreements until the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act 2013 renamed them.

The important thing to understand is that a settlement agreement is not just a payment. It is a waiver of legal rights. Ordinarily, an employee cannot contract out of statutory employment rights at all: section 203(1) of the Employment Rights Act 1996 makes such attempts void. A settlement agreement works only because sections 203(2)(f) and 203(3) create a narrow exception, and that exception applies only if strict conditions are met.

That is why the independent advice requirement exists. It is not a formality. It is the thing that makes the document enforceable.

What makes a settlement agreement legally binding?

For a settlement agreement to validly waive statutory employment claims, all six of these conditions must be satisfied:

# Condition (s.203(3) ERA 1996) What it means in practice
1 The agreement is in writing Verbal deals do not waive statutory claims
2 It relates to the particular complaint or proceedings Claims must be identified, not waived by a vague catch-all
3 You received advice from a relevant independent adviser On the terms and effect of the agreement and its effect on your ability to pursue your rights at tribunal
4 The adviser is covered by professional indemnity insurance The adviser will confirm this in an adviser’s certificate
5 The agreement identifies the adviser By name, in the document itself
6 The agreement states that the statutory conditions are satisfied Standard wording, but it must actually be there

For discrimination claims under the Equality Act 2010, the equivalent conditions are in section 147, which requires an “independent adviser” and uses the same “particular complaint” wording.

Who counts as an independent adviser?

A qualified lawyer, a certified trade union official or officer, or a certified advice centre worker. The adviser must be independent of your employer, which is why your employer’s solicitor cannot advise you.

A common misunderstanding: the adviser advises on the terms and effect of the agreement. That is the minimum statutory requirement. It does not oblige an adviser to negotiate for you, value your claims or tell you whether the deal is good. A solicitor doing the job properly will do all of those things, but if you are relying on a fixed contribution from your employer, check what is included.

What claims can and cannot be settled?

Can be settled Cannot be settled
Unfair dismissal Accrued pension rights (normally expressly carved out)
Wrongful dismissal and breach of contract Personal injury claims you do not know about at the date of signing (usually carved out)
Discrimination, harassment and victimisation under the Equality Act 2010 The right to make a protected disclosure — s.43J ERA 1996 makes any clause preventing whistleblowing void
Unlawful deduction from wages The right to report a criminal offence to the police, or to disclose to certain bodies (Victims and Prisoners Act 2024, s.17, in force 1 October 2025)
Redundancy pay claims The right to enforce the settlement agreement itself
Working time and holiday pay claims Anything you are legally compelled to disclose, e.g. under a court order or to a regulator

What about future claims you do not yet know about? In Bathgate v Technip Singapore PTE Ltd [2023] CSIH 48, the Court of Session held that a settlement agreement can waive unknown future claims, provided the waiver is plain and unequivocal and the type of claim is clearly identified in the agreement. The decision is binding in Scotland and treated as highly persuasive in England and Wales. This is why settlement agreements contain long lists of statutory claims: the list is doing real legal work, not padding.

The practical takeaway: read the list of waived claims. If something you might genuinely want to pursue is on it, that is the point at which to raise it.

When are settlement agreements used?

Settlement agreements do not imply wrongdoing by either side. Common triggers include:

  • Redundancy and restructuring, particularly where an employer wants finality rather than running a full consultation
  • Performance or capability concerns, often offered as an alternative to a formal process
  • Disciplinary or grievance proceedings
  • Allegations of discrimination, harassment or bullying
  • Long-term sickness absence and disability-related exits
  • Whistleblowing disputes
  • Breakdown in the working relationship, especially at senior level
  • Negotiated exits for directors and senior executives, where reputation and announcements matter as much as money

What should a settlement agreement contain?

Clause What to check
Termination payment The compensation for giving up your claims, over and above what you are owed anyway
Notice Whether you work it, are on garden leave, or receive a payment in lieu — and how it is taxed
Accrued salary, holiday and expenses Payable regardless of whether you sign; these should not be presented as part of the “offer”
Bonus and commission Contractual or discretionary? Pro-rated? Deferred awards and unvested shares need separate treatment
Pension Employer contributions to the termination date, and any continuation
Benefits Private medical insurance, life cover, company car, season ticket loan — when do they stop
Reference Ideally agreed wording annexed as a schedule, with an obligation to give a consistent verbal reference
Announcement Agreed internal and external wording, particularly for senior roles
Restrictive covenants Whether existing non-compete, non-solicit and non-deal clauses are repeated, released or narrowed
Confidentiality and non-derogatory statements Scope, mutuality, and permitted disclosures to family and professional advisers
Legal fees The employer’s contribution, and who pays if it costs more
Warranties and clawback Promises you are making — for example that you have no other job offer — and what happens if they are breached
Tax indemnity Standard, but check it is limited to your own tax and does not extend to the employer’s penalties or interest
Payment dates Usually 14 to 28 days after the later of the termination date and receipt of the signed agreement

Two clauses cause more regret after signing than any other: restrictive covenants and the reference. Both are usually negotiable, and neither costs the employer money, which is precisely why they are often the easiest wins.

How much should I get in a settlement agreement?

There is no standard figure, and anyone quoting a fixed formula is guessing. The correct way to assess an offer is to separate it into two parts.

Part 1: what you are owed anyway. Salary to the termination date, accrued holiday, contractual notice or pay in lieu, earned commission or bonus, expenses, and statutory redundancy pay if you are being made redundant. You would receive these whether or not you sign. They are not compensation.

Part 2: what you are being paid to sign. This is the actual offer. Compare it against what you could realistically recover at tribunal, discounted for risk, delay and cost.

Rules of thumb such as “one month per year of service” circulate widely and are unreliable. An employee with 15 years’ service and no claim may reasonably receive less than an employee with 18 months’ service and a strong discrimination case, because compensation for discrimination is uncapped and includes an award for injury to feelings.

What increases your leverage

Factor Why it matters
Procedural defects No consultation, predetermined outcome, no right of appeal — these make an unfair dismissal finding more likely
A protected characteristic in play Discrimination compensation is uncapped and includes injury to feelings, assessed under the Vento bands
A protected disclosure Whistleblowing detriment and automatically unfair dismissal claims are uncapped and need no qualifying service
Disability and reasonable adjustments Failure to adjust is frequently the strongest claim in capability and sickness absence exits
Long notice period Directly increases the cost to the employer of not settling
Difficult labour market or specialist role Longer projected loss of earnings feeds directly into the compensatory award
Reputational or regulatory sensitivity Employers pay for confidentiality and finality, particularly in regulated sectors
An unresolved grievance An outstanding grievance you have not withdrawn is a live problem for the employer

What reduces it

Short service, a genuine and well-run redundancy process, a documented performance record, a weak causal link between the treatment and any protected characteristic, and having already accepted a role elsewhere at equivalent pay, which cuts your losses and therefore your claim value.

Is the first £30,000 of a settlement agreement tax free?

No — not the first £30,000 of everything. The exemption in section 403 of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003 applies only to qualifying termination payments. It does not apply to payments that are really earnings.

Taxed in full (income tax plus employee and employer National Insurance):

  • Salary to the termination date
  • Accrued but untaken holiday pay
  • Bonus and commission
  • Contractual pay in lieu of notice
  • Post-employment notice pay (PENP) — the statutory calculation under s.402D ITEPA 2003 that treats the basic pay you would have earned during any unworked notice as earnings, however the payment is labelled

Potentially within the £30,000 exemption:

  • Genuine compensation for loss of office
  • Statutory and enhanced redundancy pay (statutory redundancy pay counts towards the £30,000, it does not sit outside it)
  • Ex gratia payments not otherwise contractual

Worked example

An employee on £60,000 (£5,000 per month) with three months’ contractual notice leaves immediately, without working notice. The agreement offers £50,000 in total described as compensation.

Element Amount Treatment
PENP (3 months’ basic pay) £15,000 Income tax + employee and employer NICs
Balance of termination payment £35,000 First £30,000 exempt
Excess over £30,000 £5,000 Income tax + employer Class 1A NICs. No employee NICs

So of a £50,000 “offer”, roughly £30,000 arrives tax free and £20,000 is taxable. This is the single most common misunderstanding in settlement negotiations, and it is worth modelling before you agree a headline number rather than after.

Anything above £30,000 attracts employer Class 1A National Insurance, which is a real cost to your employer. Where the offer is close to the threshold, there is sometimes room to restructure the package — for example by increasing an employer pension contribution, which can be paid without triggering income tax or NICs — rather than simply increasing the cash figure. Take advice on this: the tax treatment depends on how the payment is genuinely characterised, not on how it is labelled.

How long do I have to consider a settlement agreement?

The Acas Code of Practice on Settlement Agreements states that, as a general rule, you should be given a minimum of 10 calendar days to consider the proposed formal written terms and to receive advice, unless the parties agree otherwise.

The Code is not a hard deadline and 10 days is a floor rather than a target. A complex senior exit involving share awards may reasonably take longer.

If you are given 48 hours and told the offer will be withdrawn, that pressure is itself relevant. Under the Acas Code, giving an employee an unreasonably short time to decide is an example of improper behaviour, which can strip the employer of the confidentiality protection it is relying on (see the next section).

Are settlement discussions confidential?

Two separate protections are often confused.

“Without prejudice” (common law). Protects genuine attempts to settle an existing dispute from being referred to in later proceedings. If there is no existing dispute, the rule does not apply. It can also be lost where there is “unambiguous impropriety”.

“Protected conversations” (s.111A Employment Rights Act 1996). Introduced in 2013, this protects pre-termination negotiations from being used as evidence in an ordinary unfair dismissal claim even where no dispute exists yet. Its limits are significant:

  • It does not apply to discrimination, whistleblowing, automatically unfair dismissal, breach of contract, or any claim other than ordinary unfair dismissal
  • The protection is lost where there has been improper behaviour, which the Acas Code says includes undue pressure, harassment, bullying, victimisation, discrimination and physical assault
  • It covers the conversation, not the fact of the dismissal itself

In practice, if you were told “sign this or we will start a disciplinary process” and you also have a discrimination claim, the conversation may well be admissible. Employers frequently label conversations “without prejudice and protected” without either protection actually applying.

Can a settlement agreement stop me talking about discrimination or harassment?

Less than it used to, and considerably less from 2027.

The position now (September 2026):

  • Any clause preventing a protected disclosure is void: s.43J ERA 1996
  • Since 6 April 2026, disclosures about sexual harassment are expressly a qualifying disclosure for whistleblowing purposes, following the Employment Rights Act 2025’s amendment to s.43B ERA 1996. That materially widens the protection
  • Since 1 October 2025, s.17 of the Victims and Prisoners Act 2024 has made NDAs unenforceable to the extent they prevent a victim of crime disclosing information to the police, lawyers, regulators, healthcare professionals and victim support services
  • The SRA warning notice on NDAs (updated August 2024) restricts what solicitors may properly include in confidentiality clauses
  • Since 1 August 2025, the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023 has banned NDAs covering harassment complaints in the English higher education sector outright, with no exceptions

The position from 2027: Section 24 of the Employment Rights Act 2025 inserts a new section 202A into the Employment Rights Act 1996. Once in force, any provision in an agreement between an employer and a worker will be void to the extent it prevents the worker disclosing relevant harassment or discrimination, or the employer’s response to it.

There is a narrow carve-out for “excepted agreements”. The Government consulted on the conditions between 15 April and 8 July 2026, with proposals including that the NDA must be at the worker’s request, that the worker has independent legal advice, and that there is a cooling-off period. Implementation is expected during 2027; no commencement date has been confirmed. The rules will not apply retrospectively, so an agreement signed today will be governed by the current law.

If your draft agreement contains confidentiality wording connected to allegations of harassment, discrimination or whistleblowing, this is the clause to scrutinise hardest.

What is changing in 2026 and 2027, and why it affects your negotiation

The Employment Rights Act 2025 is being implemented in stages. Three changes shift the balance of power in settlement negotiations.

Date Change Effect on settlement negotiations
6 April 2026 Sexual harassment becomes a qualifying disclosure for whistleblowing; collective redundancy protective award doubled from 90 to 180 days’ pay Increases the value of harassment-related and collective redundancy claims
1 October 2026 Employment tribunal time limits extend from three months to six months for most claims Applies where the relevant act occurs on or after 1 October 2026. Removes much of the time pressure employees have historically faced, and with it some of the employer’s leverage
30 October 2026 Employers must take all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment; liability for third-party harassment returns Raises the standard employers must meet, and their exposure
1 January 2027 Unfair dismissal qualifying period drops from two years to six months, and the cap on the compensatory award is removed entirely The most significant change. The cap is currently the lower of 52 weeks’ gross pay or a statutory maximum (£118,223 for dismissals from 6 April 2025, uprated each April). Removing it substantially increases exposure for high earners
During 2027 Section 202A NDA restrictions take effect Confidentiality over harassment and discrimination becomes largely unenforceable

Why timing may matter to you. Employees with six or more months’ service on 1 January 2027 gain unfair dismissal protection immediately. If you have under two years’ service and your employer wants you out before the end of 2026, they may be moving quickly for a reason. Equally, if your termination date falls on or after 1 January 2027 and you are a high earner, uncapped compensation changes the arithmetic of what a tribunal claim is worth — and your employer’s advisers will know that.

This is a genuinely unusual moment. If your exit is being negotiated in late 2026, the termination date itself is a negotiable term with legal consequences.

Can I negotiate a settlement agreement?

Yes. Settlement agreements are voluntary and negotiable, and the Acas Code expressly contemplates proposals and counter-proposals.

Negotiation is not only about money. Terms that are frequently improved without a single extra pound changing hands:

  • The reference — agreed wording annexed to the agreement, plus a commitment that any verbal reference will be consistent with it
  • Restrictive covenants — release, reduction of duration, or narrowing of the client and geographic scope. If you have a role lined up, this can be worth more than the payment
  • Termination date — extending it preserves benefits, continues pension contributions, avoids a CV gap and may push you past a service milestone or into a more favourable legal regime
  • Bonus and share awards — treating you as a “good leaver” rather than a bad one
  • The announcement — agreed internal and external wording
  • Retention of equipment — laptop and phone are often written off
  • Outplacement support and payment of your professional subscriptions
  • A larger legal fees contribution, particularly where negotiation is genuinely needed
  • Payment timing — moving payment into the next tax year can reduce the tax on the excess over £30,000 if your income will be lower

How to negotiate credibly

Do not simply ask for more. Set out, in a without prejudice letter, the specific claims you say you have, the factual basis for each, and a valuation. Employers respond to risk, not to disappointment. A well-evidenced counter-proposal that names three viable claims will usually achieve more than an emotional appeal for double the money.

What happens if I refuse a settlement agreement?

You are under no obligation to sign. If you reject the offer:

  • Your employment continues, and any underlying process — redundancy consultation, disciplinary, capability — resumes
  • Your employer may improve the offer. Initial offers are commonly opening positions
  • You retain your claims and can bring a tribunal claim, subject to the time limits and to Acas early conciliation

Refusing is not risk-free. The working relationship may be strained, and a subsequent dismissal may still be fair if the underlying process is properly run. But rejecting an inadequate offer is a normal part of negotiation, and employers expect it.

Be aware of time limits. Acas early conciliation must normally be started before the deadline. For events before 1 October 2026 that is generally three months less one day; for events on or after that date, six months.

What happens after I sign?

The agreement becomes binding once both parties have signed and the statutory conditions are met. Typically:

  1. Your employment ends on the agreed termination date
  2. Your employer makes the agreed payments, usually within 14 to 28 days
  3. Your P45 is issued, and any taxable sums are processed through payroll
  4. You return company property and hand over passwords and files
  5. The agreed reference is provided when requested
  6. Both parties comply with confidentiality and non-derogatory statement clauses
  7. You cannot pursue the claims listed in the agreement

If your employer fails to pay, the agreement is a contract and you can sue for breach. Some agreements also make the waiver conditional on payment being made, which is a useful protection to ask for.

Common mistakes to avoid

Treating the headline figure as the offer. If £30,000 of a £45,000 “offer” is notice and holiday pay you were owed anyway, the real offer is £15,000.

Ignoring restrictive covenants. A 12-month non-compete can cost more than the entire settlement if it blocks your next role.

Assuming the first £30,000 is always tax free. It applies only to genuine termination payments, and PENP is carved out of it.

Not raising a grievance first, where appropriate. In some situations, putting the allegations on record before negotiating materially strengthens your position. In others it hardens the employer’s stance. This is a judgement call to take advice on early.

Signing under time pressure. The Acas Code says 10 calendar days. An artificial deadline is itself a negotiating tactic, and may amount to improper behaviour.

Using the employer’s panel solicitor without checking scope. Independent advice is a statutory requirement. Advice on whether the deal is fair is not, and a fixed £350 contribution rarely buys negotiation.

Comparing your deal to a colleague’s. Two people on the same salary can have completely different legal positions.

Checklist before you sign:

☐ I understand which claims I am waiving, and none of them is one I want to pursue

☐ I have separated what I am owed anyway from what I am being paid to sign

☐ I know the tax treatment of each element, including PENP

☐ I have seen and approved the reference wording

☐ I understand my restrictive covenants and how they affect my next role

☐ I know what happens to bonus, commission, pension and unvested shares

☐ The payment dates are specified

☐ The confidentiality clause is mutual and permits disclosure to my family and advisers

☐ The legal fees contribution covers my actual costs

☐ I have had a reasonable time to consider it, and I am not signing under pressure

Frequently asked questions

Is a settlement agreement the same as redundancy?

No. Redundancy is a reason for dismissal. A settlement agreement is a contract that can document the terms of any exit and waive claims. Settlement agreements are often used in redundancy situations, but the two are not the same, and signing one does not necessarily mean your dismissal was a redundancy.

Do I have to sign a settlement agreement?

No. Settlement agreements are entirely voluntary. Your employer cannot compel you to sign one, and refusing does not by itself justify dismissal.

Can my employer withdraw the offer?

Yes, until the agreement is signed by both parties it can generally be withdrawn. If an offer is withdrawn unexpectedly, take advice promptly — the circumstances may themselves give rise to a claim.

Who pays my legal fees?

Employers usually offer a contribution, commonly between £350 and £1,500 plus VAT, because independent advice is a statutory requirement for the agreement to work. They are not obliged to pay, and are not obliged to cover the full cost if negotiation is needed. Ask early whether the contribution can be increased. At Attwells we work to a fixed fee for settlement agreement advice, which in most cases is covered in full by the employer’s contribution.

Can I get more than the amount offered?

Often, yes. Whether you should push, and by how much, depends on the strength of your potential claims and the employer’s appetite for risk. Employers rarely open at their ceiling.

Can I start a new job after signing?

Usually yes, but check your notice period, any garden leave and your post-termination restrictions. Also check whether the agreement contains a warranty that you have no other employment lined up — signing that when you already have an offer can put your payment at risk.

Will a settlement agreement show up on a future employer’s background check?

No. Settlement agreements are private contracts and do not appear on any register. However, the agreed reference is what your former employer will provide, which is why the reference wording matters.

Can I still claim benefits after signing?

A settlement payment may affect entitlement to income-based benefits, and how a termination is recorded can affect Jobseeker’s Allowance. Check with your adviser and with DWP before you sign.

How long does the process take?

Typically one to three weeks from receiving the draft to signing, longer if there is meaningful negotiation or complex share awards. The Acas Code recommends a minimum of 10 calendar days for consideration.

What is a COT3, and how is it different?

A COT3 is a settlement recorded through an Acas conciliator. It achieves the same waiver of claims but does not require independent legal advice and is usually shorter. Employers sometimes prefer a settlement agreement because it can cover a wider range of terms, such as confidentiality and restrictive covenants.

Been offered a settlement agreement?

Attwells Solicitors advises employees on settlement agreements from our offices in Ipswich, Colchester, Woodbridge and London, and remotely across England and Wales. Our employment team is ranked in The Legal 500.

In a settlement agreement review we will tell you what you are actually being offered once your contractual entitlements are stripped out, identify the claims you may have, explain how each element will be taxed, and advise whether the terms are worth challenging. Where there is scope to improve the deal, we negotiate with your employer on your behalf.

We work to fixed fees, so you will not receive an unexpected bill. In most cases your employer’s contribution covers the cost of the advice.

Call Lloyd Clarke and the employment team on 01206 239761, or request a callback for a no-obligation discussion.

About the author

Lloyd Clarke is a Partner at Attwells Solicitors LLP and heads the firm’s Employment Law department, which is ranked in The Legal 500. He has over ten years’ experience in workplace disputes, acting for both employees and employers, and regularly appears in the Employment Tribunal. He also advises on business disputes and civil litigation. Lloyd is based in Attwells’ Colchester office and can be contacted on 01206 239761.

This article is general information about the law in England and Wales and is not legal advice about your individual circumstances. The law described is as at 09/09/2026 . Several of the reforms referred to in this guide have not yet come into force, and the Government’s implementation timetable may change. Attwells Solicitors LLP is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority, SRA number 466580.

CONTACT US TODAY
Related articles
  • Senior executive negotiating a settlement agreement in a corporate boardroom
    Senior executive negotiating a settlement agreement in a corporate boardroom

    November 17, 2026

  • Attwells Solicitors' Employment Law Team, featured alongside the firm's Legal 500 Leading Firm recognition for 2027.
    Attwells Solicitors' Employment Law Team, featured alongside the firm's Legal 500 Leading Firm recognition for 2027.

    November 17, 2026

  • Job applicant discussing their CV during a job interview
    Job applicant discussing their CV during a job interview

    November 17, 2026

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!